Strange Science Afoot

Fringe: Series Premiere

Fringe is one of those shows that didn’t seem like it was going to be anything special back in the day and then, somehow, became a show I couldn’t stop watching. Created by J. J. Abrams, Alex Kurtzman, and Roberto Orci, the pitch for the lay person was pretty simple: what if The X-Files had a puzzle box mystery at the center of it all. It was a series built on strange science and weird ideas and while aliens were never a factor in the storytelling (unlike in The X-Files) the concepts aligned very well. Weird and paranormal activities that require a crack team of weirdos, including at least one FBI agent, to solve, all set against a mysterious background you really wanted to understand. Oh, and it aired on Fox, just as The X-Files had before.

The simple pitch of Fringe was obviously just a way to get people through the door. Even in the first episode of the series, Fringe makes it clear that it’s more than just some weird little The X-Files clone. It wants to go hard, to gross people out, to tell strange stories that not even The X-Files was interested in telling. Yes, it had a mystery at its core, but that mystery was more than some simple, “ooh, aliens,” plot device. They wanted you to study, to connect the dots, to pay attention to all the beats of the story. They wanted you to believe.

But not like with The X-Files: I Want to Believe. The truth was out there, but it was in a very different direction.

Fringe, especially in the pilot episode, focuses on three main characters. The first is Olivia Dunham (Anna Torv), an FBI agent acting as liaison between the various governmental agencies. In her position as a cross-agency liaison, she’s called to the scene of a very strange incident on a flight. The plane landed (due to its auto-pilot taking over) while everyone on board was dead. They all seemingly dissolved and liquified as huge parts of their bodies went transparent. The various agencies think this was terrorism, but Dunham has questions that can’t be answered by the evidence at hand.

Things take a turn when Dunham and her partner (and lover), John Scott (Mark Valley), go out to investigate a possible lead at a storage facility. As it turns out, the lead was spot on and they stumble onto a full lab making god knows what. The terrorist escapes, but only after blowing up his lab, catching John in the explosion. His body starts to deteriorate, not unlike the people on the plane, and Dunham has to find someone that can help her. That’s when, in her research, she finds out about Dr. Walter Bishop (John Noble), a brilliant scientist doing experiments that resemble the things Dunham saw on the plane (and that are killing John). Bishop, though, has been in a mental institution for over a decade, and the only way to get to him is through family, so Dunham has to track down Bishop’s son, Peter (Joshua Jackson), so she can get to Walter and get whatever truth might be out there.

Going back and watching this pilot again makes its strangeness really stick out. Bear in mind I’ve watched this series probably three times through so far (once when it originally aired, and then twice more once I had it on DVD) so I know the beats of the show and how it plays out in later seasons. The series has a formula, and while it does a very good job of playing with that formula, changing up beats and layering on all kinds of weirdness, there’s a core story structure: a case comes in, the team has to figure out what’s going on, and then they track down the bad guy to stop the bad things best as they can. It’s loose, but it works.

This first episode, though, doesn’t really do that at all. Yes, Dunham is called in on a case, the mysterious deaths of everyone on board this dead flight, but she then spends half the episode not focusing directly on the case. Once John gets blowed up good and covered in nasty goo that starts to dissolve him, Dunham’s focus switches from finding the bad guy to finding a cure for John, and that means Walter and Peter Bishop become her focus. We don’t actually get back around to the main plot until the last twenty minutes or so (when, spoilers for a two decade old show) John is revealed to be in cahoots with the terrorist, making him the bad guy they’ve been chasing this whole time.

The episode is weird. Its pacing is different, its beats are different, and the whole flow of the episode feels very off. Dunham functionally has to fight just about everyone around her, with Peter butting heads with her because he forces him to work with her, to her new boss, Phillip Broyles (the always fantastic Lance Reddick), who dislikes Oliva because of a past case she worked that put away one of Broyles’s colleagues. And all of that disappears after this episode. I’m sure the creators got notes that said, “stop having everyone be a dick to Olivia,” and they rewrote the character dynamics to compensate.

Which is good because while I can appreciate that Olivia has to fight to work this weird case and gain the trust of the people around her, if we had to watch that every episode it would have become tiring. It feels like the writers were trying very hard to not make Dunham into a Mary Sue here and then realized they went too far in the other direction and had to pull things back. She’s a great character here, powered by a solid performance by Anna Torv, but the show still had to figure out how to build the world around her.

But then, speaking of great actors, everyone on this show is fantastic. Noble brings a solid air of a mad scientist to his performance as Walter Bishop, but with a kind and caring soul underneath it all. He’s like Frankenstein, but with a big old heart. Joshua Jackson does solid work making everyone forget he was Pacey on Dawson’s Creek, playing a slimier con-man with his own heart of gold on the show, which even comes across in this first episode. And, naturally, Lance Reddick is great even if he’s underused here (he will get more time to develop his character as the series continues).

Of course, what really sucks people in is the strangeness of the case, and this first one was clearly made to be eye grabbing. People on a plane suddenly finding themselves infected with a pathogen that causes them to go transparent, liquify, and fall apart, all while we watch it happen is a shocking way to start a series. It promises body horror, nightmares, and a lot of cool special effects. If you sit through the initial scene and decide you want more, then the show absolutely has its hooks in you. It’s a test to see if you want to come back for more and, considering it went for five seasons, plenty of people came back for more.

But it’s also clear that the show was finding its footing even as it set up a solid case and great characters. It hints at a larger plotline in this first episode, “The Pattern”, and then doesn’t really define it. “Strange things are happening, a series of weird events that indicate something greater is going on.” It’s a clue to more without really saying what that more is. And who knows if, originally, the creators even knew what that storyline would be. J.J. Abrams is famous for creating stories that have a puzzle box at their center but no solutions built within. The answers come later, after the box is built, and frequently the answers aren’t really all that great (like with Lost, or with Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker). Fringe could seem to have that same problem here, a mystery box without a clear solution waiting, just vague hints and ideas, so audiences had to decide if it was worth the investigation to see what came next.

Enough did, of course. I certainly did. And even if this first episode isn’t like the episodes that would come after in a number of ways, it does still feel like Fringe. The world, the characters, the weird science. This is a show that basically had its concept set from the beginning, and the rest of it could be figured out as we went along. Thankfully, the journey was worth it…