The Ties of Family
Criminal, Vol 2: "Lawless"
When last we looked at Criminal, Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips’s anthology series about the crime genre, it was with their first volume, “Coward”, a tale about a man who always saw all the angles, who never took a misstep when it came to his crimes and schemes, only to then find himself in a situation where he can’t easily find his way out, where the only path is through, and that likely means he won’t come out the other the other side. It was a dark and grounded tale that set the tone for the series to come. But it was also just one story unconnected to the rest of the world.
With the second volume, “Lawless”, we see the world continue to take shape, and what becomes clear here is that Criminal isn’t set on making a tight and cohesive world. Sure, there may be elements that carry from one story to the next. A town name, a bar, maybe a lone figure who reappears as a background extra. But these elements aren’t emphasized, aren’t the focus, and they aren’t meant to make you anticipate where the stories could go next. Brubaker and Phillips aren’t building a taught world of interconnected stories, not in the same way that Kurt Busiek was with his Silver Age-inspired superhero anthology, Astro City.
Brubaker and Phillips wanted to meditate on the crime genre as a whole to drill down and examine its tropes, to see what really made it tick. The goal was to tear it apart and make something different. Not a comic book like fans of capes and cowls would expect, but a world that just happened to fit onto a comic page because that was the medium these artists worked in. The books would be different and meaner and really dig into the characters and the situations without worrying about how it all connected.
I think that’s something that people reading the series for the first time might have struggled with if they’d picked it up issue-to-issue. Criminal was first published as an ongoing series, with Volume 2 comprising issues #6 through #10. The transition from issue #5, the tail end of “Coward” would lead into the start of “Lawless” without any further word on the previous story (not that it needed much as, spoilers for that first volume, that main character was dead), and readers had to settle into a new story with new characters in a different scenario, all without a run up. Would that work for readers? That’s something each person picking up the book had to figure out.
Going back and rereading the second volume now, I won’t deny the transition feels abrupt. There were hints that these stories took place in the same world. Tracy Lawless, a former Marine with a chip on his shoulder and a bad attitude, comes to Center City (the same city as the first volume) a year after his brother dies, looking for answers. He ends up, under an assumed name, working for the same crew that, he assumed, killed his brother, and as he works his way into their crew, he gets the answers he was looking for, even if they weren’t the answers he really wanted.
Aside from Center City itself, Lawless is our first major connection between books, but it is a subtle one. Tracy Lawless is the son of Teegar Lawless, and as we learned in the first book, the father of Leo Patterson (protagonist of that book) killed Teegar Lawless. So names recur, some connections are made, but if you aren’t paying attention, if you don’t memorize every name that’s mentioned a couple of times as background information, you might not even realize a connection is there at all.
The stories are very different, too. Both books focus on heists, but one is about drug running and double-crosses and the sins of the past, while the other is about a bank heist, love, loss, and the sins of the past… Okay, sure, that last part carries through. Functionally they are two very different stories that just so happen to take place in the same city. But if you didn’t realize the characters were loosely connected, if you weren’t paying attention to the fact that both stories took place in Center City, you’d think you were just reading about crimes and criminals in a general world.
Long term I think that actually benefits the series. Those that want to dig into the books can find connections and tease out stories and clues. But for a general reader, the stories themselves are strong enough that the creators don’t have to slap the connections in your face. The stories stand on their own, drawing you in with their tales of bad characters doing bad things, in a city that doesn’t necessarily reward them but that also doesn’t really seem to hate them, either. They find whatever punishment they deserve, even if it’s not at the end of the gun.
In the case of Tracy Lawless, our protagonist for book two (but absolutely don’t call him a hero), he’s been running from the memory of his father his whole life. His father was an abusive asshole, both to Tracy and his brother, and Tracy’s only means of escape was enlisting in the military. He found he was good at it, being a soldier, a killer, even if he wasn’t also great at taking orders (and that last bit is what gets him thrown in a military prison for six months). His return to Center City is all about making up for his past, for abandoning his younger brother while he tries, as hard as he can, to not become his father… only to fail at that, too, falling into the same like his father once had.
It’s an interesting story as it speaks to that classic trope of history always repeating. You can run from who you are but the past always catches up with you. And there’s also the thread about not seeking revenge, how you’ll have to dig two graves when you do because one of them will be for you. Tracy finds a kind of ending in this book (I won’t spoil it too much) and it’s at least an emotional death for him, a realization that he can’t escape his past, his father’s legacy, or himself, ending up right where he never wanted to be all along.
Around that we get a heist story that, if I’m being honest, is the weakest part of the story. The book introduces a whole crew that Tracy’s brother used to ride with, but most of them don’t really get development. They’re just extras on the page, nondescript bad guys to take up space and make the crew seem full. A little more shading and development for these guys would have been nice so there was a bit of mystery surrounding who killed Tracy’s brother and why.
As it stands, only one of the crew, Mallory, gets any development. She was in love with Tracy’s brother, and he was an asshole to her. The book tries to play it coy and tease things out slowly, but when you only have one character getting any development, it becomes pretty clear who the killer is and, once you learn about Tracy’s family you can guess why she ended up killing him. None of it feels like a revelation the way I think the book intended. It’s too basic, too matter of fact, which undercuts the storytelling just a little.
What carries the book is Tracy, a dark and forbidding character who is, oddly, a compelling person to read about. This is his story, through and through, and as we watch him slide into this life, becoming the criminal he never wanted to be, we get a full and complete tale. Not everything around Tracy works as well as it could, but Tracy himself is a strong enough character to carry the story, so you don’t mind as much.
Criminal is a generally strong book that works well doing one thing: giving us compelling central characters to watch as they slowly descend into darkness. As the series continues I’m sure we’ll get many more of these kinds of characters, and the subtle connections that unite them all. And it’s clear that at the very least, these characters are going to be compelling enough to carry the series even if the stories around them aren’t always the strongest.